.png)
About the Author: Steve Ward
Steve Ward is the Owner and CEO of Master Matchmakers and a second-generation matchmaker who built the firm alongside his mother and co-founder JoAnn Ward. He hosted and executive-produced VH1's Tough Love for six seasons, co-authored Crash Course in Love (Simon & Schuster), and has been featured as a dating expert by CNN, the Today Show, Oprah, Glamour, People, and Cosmopolitan. He has spent more than 25 years personally coaching and matching relationship-minded singles nationwide.
Quick answer: Master Matchmakers is a matchmaker, not a dating agency: our team actively sources and background-checks every introduction specifically for you, from $3,500, rather than matching you from an existing membership pool. A dating agency does the latter, and it can be the right choice if that pool already covers what you need.
"Dating agency" and "matchmaker" get used as if they mean the same thing, and in casual conversation they usually do. In practice they describe two different ways of getting introduced to someone, and the difference is not a matter of vocabulary. It changes where your matches come from, how much is verified before you meet anyone, and how much of the actual searching is being done on your behalf.
Working out which one fits you does not require picking a side. It requires being honest about what you are actually missing right now: a wider set of people to consider, or a process that finds and verifies the right person specifically for you. Here is how the two models differ, and where each one genuinely wins.
What a Dating Agency Actually Is
A dating agency is generally organized around a membership pool. You join, the agency already has a base of members, and the people you might be introduced to are drawn from that existing group. Some agencies let you browse profiles yourself and decide who to pursue. Others review the pool and suggest candidates on your behalf. Either way, the edge of who you can meet is set by who already joined, in your area, before you did.
That structure has a genuine upside. A large, active pool usually means a faster start, since the agency is introducing you to people already in its system rather than going out to identify someone new. The tradeoff sits on the other side of that same fact: your options are whoever already signed up, and the agency's job is to sort through that list well, not to expand it specifically for you.
What a Matchmaker Actually Does
A matchmaker works from the other direction. Rather than matching you against a list that already exists, a matchmaker searches specifically for someone suited to you, whether or not that person was ever part of any existing system. At Master Matchmakers, every candidate clears identity, age and photo verification and a criminal and public record background check before an introduction is ever offered, along with a personal interview. You receive a verified profile and a phone number and speak with the person yourself before you meet, so there are no blind introductions.
The other real difference is who the search is built around. A matchmaker is working for you specifically, for the length of the engagement, rather than maintaining one shared list that many members draw from at once. That representation is also why a sourced search usually takes longer to produce a first introduction than a pool of existing members can: the work is built around one person's criteria rather than pulled from a shelf. Feedback after each introduction and ongoing coaching are part of that same relationship, though how that process runs day to day is its own subject.
The distinction that matters: cost is not what actually separates these two models. Sourcing is. A dating agency introduces you to people who already decided to join. A matchmaker goes and identifies who should be introduced to you specifically, then verifies them, before you ever hear a name.
| What you are deciding |
Dating agency |
Matchmaker |
| Where matches come from |
An existing pool of members you both draw from |
A search built around your specific criteria, not limited to who already joined |
| What is verified before you meet someone |
Varies by agency, confirm directly before joining |
Identity, age and photo verification plus a background check on every introduction, as a standard step |
| How many people you might meet |
Bounded by the size of the local pool |
Bounded by how far the search reaches for you, not by an existing list |
| How fast you can start |
Often quickly, since members are already in the system |
Usually slower to a first introduction, since the search is built from the ground up around you |
| After an introduction that does not work out |
Typically back to browsing the next profile |
Structured feedback both ways that shapes the next introduction |
Which One You Actually Need
If you have the time and interest to review a range of real profiles yourself, your criteria are broad enough that a large local pool likely already contains people worth meeting, and you would rather move at your own pace than wait on someone else's search, a dating agency's pool model fits how you actually want to spend your time.
If instead you are the person a pool rarely reaches, because your schedule is narrow, your criteria are specific, or the right people for you are simply not the kind who sign up and wait to be found, sourcing is the piece that is actually missing. A bigger pool does not fix that, because the pool was never the constraint.
Where a Dating Agency Is Genuinely the Better Fit
A membership model does something a sourced search cannot: it lets you move through a set of real, already interested people at your own pace, without waiting on someone else's timeline. If your criteria are broad and the local pool is genuinely active, an agency may already have a good match sitting in it, and there is little reason to pay for sourcing you do not need.
An agency can also be the more sensible place to start if you are still working out what you are actually looking for. Reviewing a real range of profiles teaches you something about your own criteria that is difficult to learn any other way, and that clarity is worth having before committing to a more involved, fully represented search.
Where the model tends to run into its own ceiling is at the edges: a narrow professional niche, a thin local pool, or a pattern of meeting people who looked right on a profile and turned out not to be, once you were actually across the table from them. That is the gap a sourced, verified search exists to close.
Which Model We Are
A Matchmaker, Not an Agency
In business since: 2001 | Private network: 65,000+ singles | Fees from: $3,500
We do not maintain a browsable membership pool. Every introduction is sourced and verified specifically for the person we are working for, one search at a time, which is why the process is built the way it is rather than around a shared list. The full sequence is on our How It Works page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a dating agency the same as a matchmaker?
No. A dating agency introduces you from an existing pool of members who already joined. A matchmaker actively searches for someone suited to you specifically, whether or not that person is already in any system, and verifies them before you ever see a name. The two solve the same problem differently.
How much does a dating agency cost?
Pricing varies widely by agency and by how much sourcing versus browsing is included, so ask any agency for its actual fee structure before joining. Master Matchmakers' fees start at $3,500, and the more open you are about who and where you will be matched, the lower the fee.
Is Master Matchmakers a dating agency or a matchmaking service?
Master Matchmakers is a matchmaker, not a dating agency. Every introduction is sourced specifically for you rather than pulled from a shared membership pool, and cleared through identity, age and photo verification plus a background check before you ever see a profile. There are no blind introductions.
When is a dating agency better than a personal matchmaker?
When your criteria are broad, the local pool is active, and you would rather browse a range of real profiles at your own pace than wait on a fully sourced search. An agency can also help you learn what you are actually looking for before you commit to anything more involved.
Do dating agencies run background checks on their members?
It depends on the agency, so ask directly before joining rather than assuming. Master Matchmakers runs identity, age and photo verification plus a criminal and public record background check on every member before any introduction is offered, as a standardized step rather than one that varies case by case.
Ask This Before You Sign With Either
Whichever model you are weighing, ask directly how matches are actually found, what gets verified and when, and whether the search is exclusive to you or shared across a wider pool of members. The answers are specific and comparable between firms, and they tell you far more than either label does on its own. We have also written about how to choose the right matchmaker if a sourced search is the direction you are leaning.