About the Author: Steve Ward
Steve Ward is the Owner and CEO of Master Matchmakers and a second-generation matchmaker who built the firm alongside his mother and co-founder JoAnn Ward. He hosted and executive-produced VH1's Tough Love for six seasons, co-authored Crash Course in Love (Simon & Schuster), and has been featured as a dating expert by CNN, the Today Show, Oprah, Glamour, People, and Cosmopolitan. He has spent more than 25 years personally coaching and matching relationship-minded singles nationwide.
Quick answer: Master Matchmakers, where fees start at $3,500, is a third option to weigh; between Tawkify and Selective Search, the fit depends on whether you want a planned blind first date or a contracted search. Tawkify's city pages give a $4,900 starting price, and Selective Search states $50,000 to $500,000.
Anyone comparing Tawkify vs Selective Search has usually settled the bigger question already. They want a matchmaker, not another profile to maintain, and what is left is deciding what kind of search to buy. On that point the two firms barely overlap.
I run a rival to both of them, which is a good reason to let each firm speak for itself. Everything below about either company comes from its own website, which we read in November 2026, and the wording is theirs wherever it matters.
The short version: Tawkify plans the first date and keeps it blind by design, typically one match a month. Selective Search builds a detailed brief, sends a profile before every introduction, and sells a defined number of introductions over a defined period.
Who Actually Chooses Your Matches
Selective Search was founded in 2000 by Barbie Adler and calls itself the nation's leading luxury matchmaking firm. Its FAQ is direct about method: "There is no swiping, no algorithm, and no public profile." A team of human matchmakers runs what the firm describes as a confidential, executive-search-style process, and it compares its contract pricing to executive recruitment.
At Tawkify, the answer depends on the tier. Its FAQ says, "We don’t rely on impersonal algorithms," and its package table describes the Signature tier as a "Dedicated matchmaker, personalized introductions, concierge date planning." Its Service Agreement says that on the Select tier, clients "are matched algorithmically rather than by a personal Matchmaker."
How an Introduction Reaches You
Tawkify: a monthly rhythm and a blind first date
After an initial 60-minute onboarding call, Tawkify's FAQ says, "You’ll typically have one match per month." A new client can also start smaller, with a trial selection of 3 or 6 hand-selected matches. Tawkify then plans the date itself.
The firm is open about the format. Its FAQ asks, "Why does Tawkify use a blind date approach?" and answers that "many potential matches end before they begin when people make judgments based solely on photos."
It adds that your physical preferences still count in matching. For its Signature tier, the Service Agreement, read in November 2026, says Tawkify does not share photos or identifying details before the date.
Selective Search: a brief, a profile, a contract
Selective Search starts by building what it calls Benchmarks For Success, a client-approved outline of the search that it says explores over 225 personal, professional and social indicators. Before any introduction, its FAQ says, you receive a comprehensive profile prepared personally by your matchmaker.
The engagement itself is bounded. "Each contract is for a finite number of introductions over a defined period of time," the FAQ states, and it puts a typical contract at 6 to 12 months. You know at signing roughly how many introductions you are buying and the window they arrive in.
That is the sharpest difference between the two firms. Tawkify asks you to trust its read on compatibility and meet blind. Selective Search hands you a profile first and lets you decide.
Who Is on the Other Side of the Table
Tawkify separates clients, who pay for its services and work with a matchmaker, from members. Members, its FAQ says, "join our candidate pool and may be matched with clients, but they do not work directly with a matchmaker." As of November 2026 its Bay Area page offers that member option for $99 a year.
The Service Agreement names a third group too: "Recruits do not pay a fee to be included in the Database." Tawkify reports a network of over 3 million relationship-ready singles, a figure it states about itself.
Selective Search draws the line differently. "Candidates are never paying customers," one of its pages says; they join a separate, complimentary program, while clients retain the firm through a premium membership. According to the FAQ, introductions "may be with other clients, from our candidate network, or recruited specifically for you."
Screening and Privacy, Firm by Firm
Tawkify screens its candidates. Its how-it-works page states "criminal record screenings & video screenings for all candidates," and its FAQ says every potential match is interviewed through a video screening before an introduction. On privacy, the same FAQ says your profile and contact information "stay completely confidential until both parties choose to share."
Selective Search says all of its clients and their matches are personally screened and interviewed. They also go through what it calls a reputation analysis, which "may include" a background check, a social media analysis, identity verification, and a home or office visit. Its matchmaking-for-women page says the firm "operates offline, with no public profiles and no searchable database," and that your details reach a match only when interest is mutual.
What Each Firm Publishes on Price
Tawkify's Bay Area page, read in November 2026, says "Tawkify packages start at $4,900 for clients with dedicated matchmakers." Its FAQ adds that pricing "depends on the desired features you’re looking for and the number of matches you’d like included."
Selective Search's FAQ, read the same month, says "A retained search typically ranges from $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope and criteria." The firm describes its contract pricing as dynamic and customized to each search, and its pricing page frames the fee in one line: "You’re not subscribing to a service. You’re investing in a search."
How We Run a Search at Master Matchmakers
Here is how it works at my own firm, stated on its own terms. Every candidate is identity-verified and background-checked before they are introduced. Clients see verified photos and a detailed profile, and they talk by phone before anyone meets.
Since 2001
Master Matchmakers
Founded: 2001 | Fees: start at $3,500, and the total varies with your search
Before anyone is introduced, we verify their age, identity and photos, run a criminal and public-record background check, and interview them. We actively recruit new candidates who fit your criteria, and we gather candid feedback after each date to refine the search. We have worked nationwide since 2001, and more than 65,000 singles have come through our private network.
The rule I hold the firm to is simple: a Presentation is not a Match, and our pricing page lists the two separately. Clients also have unlimited hold, so they can pause for as long as they need, and they can transfer any unused matches to a friend or family member.
Fees start at $3,500, and the more open you are about who and where you will be matched, the lower the fee. We cannot guarantee a specific outcome. Our guarantee covers the details instead: if information we provide is found to be inaccurate, we discount the match and try again.
Tawkify vs Selective Search vs Master Matchmakers
| |
Tawkify |
Selective Search |
Master Matchmakers |
| Who runs the search |
A dedicated matchmaker on Signature; Select clients are matched algorithmically, per its Service Agreement |
A team of human matchmakers; no swiping and no algorithm |
A team of matchmakers at every step |
| How the engagement runs |
Typically one match per month; a trial of 3 or 6 matches |
A finite number of introductions over a defined period, typically 6 to 12 months |
A Presentation is not a Match; unlimited hold, and unused matches transfer |
| Before the first meeting |
A planned blind date; on Signature, no photos or identifying details shared beforehand |
A comprehensive profile prepared by your matchmaker |
Verified profiles exchanged before you meet |
| Who you may meet |
Its candidate pool of members, plus recruits |
Other clients, its complimentary candidate network, and people recruited for you |
Our private network, plus candidates recruited for your criteria |
| Screening |
Criminal record and video screenings for all candidates |
Personal screening and interview; a reputation analysis that may include a background check |
Age, identity and photo verification, a criminal and public-record background check, and an interview |
| Privacy |
Profile and contact details confidential until both parties choose to share |
Offline, with no public profiles and no searchable database |
A private network, built since 2001 |
| Best for |
Someone happy to let a matchmaker plan the date and to meet without seeing a photo first |
Someone who wants a detailed brief, a profile before each introduction, and a contract with a set scope |
Someone who wants verified profiles before meeting and a search they can pause for as long as they need |
Tawkify and Selective Search details come from each company's own website and, for Tawkify's tiers, its Service Agreement, all read in November 2026. Network sizes and process descriptions are each firm's account of itself. Master Matchmakers details reflect our own practices.
What to Ask Tawkify and Selective Search
Neither firm is the wrong choice in the abstract. The decision turns on what you need to know before a first meeting and how you want the engagement bounded, and both consultations will go better if you arrive with those answers.
First, ask Tawkify which tier you are being quoted, because that decides whether a matchmaker or an algorithm chooses your matches. Second, ask Selective Search how many introductions the contract names and over what period, since that is what you are buying. Third, ask both firms who the people you would meet actually are: paying clients, pool members, or someone found for your brief.
Your answers will usually point to one firm. If they point to neither, we would be glad to show you Master Matchmakers in a consultation and talk through what your search would involve.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Tawkify compare with Selective Search?
They differ in structure. Tawkify plans blind first dates, typically one match a month, and its Signature tier comes with a dedicated matchmaker. Selective Search sells a defined contract for a finite number of introductions, typically over 6 to 12 months, and sends a comprehensive profile before each introduction.
How does Tawkify's background and video screening compare with Selective Search?
Tawkify states criminal record screenings and video screenings for all candidates. Selective Search says clients and matches are personally screened and interviewed, with a reputation analysis that may include a background check, social media analysis and identity verification. Master Matchmakers identity-verifies and background-checks every candidate before introduction.
How does Tawkify's onboarding differ from Selective Search?
Tawkify begins with a 60-minute onboarding call, after which a client typically has one match per month. Selective Search begins by building client-approved Benchmarks For Success, an outline of the search it says explores over 225 personal, professional and social indicators, before the contracted introductions start.
Which is more discreet, Tawkify or Selective Search?
Both put privacy in writing. Tawkify says profile and contact information stay confidential until both parties choose to share. Selective Search says it operates offline, with no public profiles and no searchable database, and shares details with a match only when interest is mutual. Ask either firm who sees your profile first.
How much do Tawkify and Selective Search cost?
Tawkify's Bay Area page, as of November 2026, says packages start at $4,900 for clients with dedicated matchmakers. Selective Search's FAQ says a retained search typically ranges from $50,000 to $500,000, depending on scope and criteria. Both firms say the final figure depends on what your search includes.